Wednesday May 24 2017

Family law experts raise concern over 'special contribution' divorce argument

London-based family law firm Hunter & Uro is calling for 'clarity and consistency' when it comes to arguing special contribution divorce cases in court.

Family law experts raise concern over 'special contribution' divorce argument

Earlier this month news broke that a Russian billionaire has been ordered to pay his estranged wife £453 million in a divorce settlement, after a hearing at the High Court.

The settlement has been described as one of the biggest made by a UK court. The husband argued that he had made a ‘special contribution’ to the generation of wealth, but the judge concluded the couple had made ‘equal contributions to the welfare of the family’ and the husband 'did not explain in his statements precisely why he could be said to have made a stellar contribution’.

This case follows the recent publicity surrounding Ryan Giggs’ request for a ‘special contribution’ to be considered in his divorce case, which is yet to go to court.

Family law specialists Hunter & Uro want to raise awareness of this issue and the difficulties it presents for solicitors and clients.

Philip Hunter, Partner at Hunter & Uro, says: “In some divorce cases, wealthy people who want to avoid an even split of their marital assets can argue for a bigger slice of the pot, providing they can prove they made a ‘special contribution’ towards the financial welfare of the family.

“Evidence of this could be ‘an exceptional and individual quality which deserves special treatment, whether by genius in business or some other field’, or if the level of earnings is so ‘obvious and gross’ that equality of division is deemed unnecessary.

“However, the ‘special contribution’ concept is being inconsistently applied by the courts, creating waves of uncertainty for law practitioners and client alike. The courts have made it abundantly clear that there will not be a threshold of ‘obvious and gross’ wealth accumulation that justifies a special contribution award.”

Citing a case in 2016, when 16-time world darts champion Phil Taylor and his ex-wife Yvonne went to court to settle their financial dispute after the breakdown of their marriage, Pui Uro, also Partner at Hunter & Uro adds: “It might be argued that Mr Taylor’s sporting abilities are so extreme that he is touched with sporting ‘genius’, with this spark being the primary means for the family generating substantial wealth.

“Mrs Taylor had never worked since the parties were married in 1988, devoting herself to their children and grandchildren. Nevertheless, the court stated that the parties, who had assets measured in multi-millions, had made equal contributions to welfare of the family.

“There are plenty of examples of parties with vast wealth accumulated during a marriage that have unsuccessfully pursued special contribution arguments. In practice, claims for special contribution tend only to arise in cases of great wealth generated by a party's success, usually in business, during the marriage. However, focusing on issues other than pure monetary wealth, e.g. genius or exceptional skill in sport, may make it less obvious as to whether that substantial wealth generated during the marriage is or is not the product of a special contribution.”

“I think it’s important that more awareness is raised over this issue in a bid to achieve more clarity and consistency in the determination of these special contribution claims by the courts. In the meantime, I’d urge practitioners to exercise extreme caution when undertaking these kind of complex matrimonial cases, and clients to seek expert help and guidance from established specialists in this field.”

For further information on Hunter & Uro, visit www.hunteranduro.co.uk or email info@hunteranduro.co.uk.

"The special contribution concept is being inconsistently applied by the courts, creating waves of uncertainty for law practitioners and client alike."
Philip Hunter

DISCLAIMER: The statements, opinions, views and advice expressed in this article are those of the author/organisation and not of ENTIRELY. This article should represent information correct at the time of publication however whilst every care has been taken to present up-to-date and accurate information, we cannot guarantee that inaccuracies will not occur. ENTIRELY will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within this article or any information accessed through this site. The content of any organisations websites which you link to from ENTIRELY are entirely out of the control of ENTIRELY, and you proceed at your own risk. These links are provided purely for your convenience and do not imply any endorsement of or association with any products, services, content, information or materials offered by or accessible to you at the organisations site.

Entirely Law Jobs

Part Time Legal PA 3 days a week

Central London

Global financial services firm seeking temporary PA to Head of Legal.

Legal PA

City of London

Description Job Description Job Title: Legal PA Practice Group: Risk Advisory Services Department: Technology, Media & Telecommunications (TMT) Location: London office Hours of work: Monday to Friday - 09.

Legal Administrator - Tax 12 month FTC


Legal Administrator - Tax 12 Month FTC £25,000 - £31,000 & Competitive Benefits Globally Successful Law Firm Are you able to hit the ground running, learn fast and provide administrative support at a high standard of quality? A fantastic Legal Administrator opportunity has arisen, perfect for someone who is focused on career progression within the legal environment! Legal Administrator Respons.

Graduate Scheme Recruitment Role - Legal & Law

Central London

Want a company that works with the top Legal firms and Lawyers? Want a company that provides graduates with an excellent training scheme to help you excel from the very beginning of your post University career? I am currently working with a company thatis a market leader in Legal Recruitment, with many years in business, a strong Legal client base, repeat business and clear training program Graduates will be joining an establis.


City of London

A fantastic opportunity has arisen for TWO Events Coordinators to join an award winning law firm in the City.

Legal Assistant

Harrow Weald

Job Title: Legal Assistant: CommercialLocation: Harrow, HA1 2XYEmployer: Pertemps Recruitment for Harrow CouncilContract Type: Temp / Full timeA fantastic opportunity within Harrow Council for an enthusiastic and committed individual to join us as a Legal Assistant: Commercial.

Legal Secretary


My client a Law firm based in Sidcup are looking for an experienced Legal Secretary.

Practice Manager


PRACTICE MANAGER - PRESTIGIOUS CITY LAW FIRM! Practice Manager: Our client - a fantastic City law firm are now looking to bring in a Practice Manager to provide strategic support the Head of their biggest department as well as supporting smaller practice groups within the organisation.

Legal Counsel - Claims


My client, a multidisciplinary consultancy, are seeking a qualified legal professional, with experience in dealing with performance/breach of contract claims against design professionals and other construction service providers.

Legal PA

City of London

An exciting opportunity to join an international law firm following their recent restructure.

Legal Administrator


Our prestigious and well-known client based in Uxbridge are looking for a new team member to join them as a legal administrator.


MYHSM Collaborates With Equinix

In a development which reinforces its position as a worldwide service provider, MYHSM Ltd., the global provider of Payment Hardware Security Modules HSMs as a Service, announces a collaboration with Equinix, the global interconnection and data centre company

Discover the latest Industry News & Opinions on Entirely

We build powerful Financial Models for critical business decision makers.