s Darlington law firm warns farming families following landmark ruling
Entirely Law

NORTHEAST LEGAL NEWS

Tuesday June 4 2019


Darlington law firm warns farming families following landmark ruling




Darlington law firm warns farming families following landmark ruling

Darlington-based law firm Latimer Hinks has highlighted to the agricultural community just how important it is to undertake proper planning at an early stage following a landmark proprietary estoppel judgment relating to a family farming business.

The recent case centred on the estate of farming business owner Frank Habberfield, and a dispute between his 82-year old widow and youngest daughter about ownership. When Frank passed away in 2014, he left his entire estate to his wife. However, his daughter Lucy brought a claim against her mother alleging that her parents had promised her ownership of the farm upon their retirement. Mrs Habberfield denied this claim.

The England and Wales High Court found in favour of Lucy, and her mother will now be forced to sell the home she has occupied for 40 years in order to fulfil the £1.17 million cash settlement awarded to her daughter.

Rosanne Tweddle, a solicitor at Latimer Hinks who specialises in agricultural and commercial property, said: “Proprietary estoppel relates to promises being made with regard to the ownership of property or land and reliance upon those promises. There have been several cases about proprietary estoppel over the past few years involving farming families as children regularly play an active role in the running of the business, often under the impression that one day, the farm will become theirs.

“Due to the multi-generational nature of farming and a commonplace reluctance of families to discuss succession planning, arguments can easily arise, especially if children feel they are contributing as much as, or even more than their parents to the day-to-day running of the farm. This, coupled with words of encouragement by parents, can lead to disputes if their expected stake in ownership doesn’t materialise.”

Elizabeth Armstrong, a director and solicitor in the Private Client Department and Head of the Tax and Trust Department at Latimer Hinks, said: “It is essential that all business families, particularly those involved in farming make it clear exactly what their businesses own, who owns which properties, and who will eventually inherit which assets when the senior members of the family pass away.

“This case has also shown that if promises are made regarding ownership, they should be clearly thought through, written down and agreed by all those involved. In this instance, an 82-year old will lose the home she has occupied for approximately half her life based on the fact that things she and her late husband had said, alongside their daughter’s reliance on those things have resulted in assets passing to the daughter when perhaps that wasn’t the parent’s intention.

“Much of the lengthy and costly dispute which involved court proceedings and an appeal could have been avoided had the family put in place a properly thought out succession plan.”



"This case has also shown that if promises are made regarding ownership, they should be clearly thought through, written down and agreed by all those involved."
Elizabeth Armstrong, Latimer Hinks








DISCLAIMER: The statements, opinions, views and advice expressed in this article are those of the author/organisation and not of ENTIRELY. This article should represent information correct at the time of publication however whilst every care has been taken to present up-to-date and accurate information, we cannot guarantee that inaccuracies will not occur. ENTIRELY will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within this article or any information accessed through this site. The content of any organisations websites which you link to from ENTIRELY are entirely out of the control of ENTIRELY, and you proceed at your own risk. These links are provided purely for your convenience and do not imply any endorsement of or association with any products, services, content, information or materials offered by or accessible to you at the organisations site.






Discover our Industry Magazines
















Discover our UK Regional Magazines


North West Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely North West UK
East of England Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely East England UK
Ireland Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely Ireland
London Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely London UK
Midlands Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely Midlands UK
North East Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely North East UK
Scotland Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely Scotland
South East Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely South East UK
South West Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely South West UK
Wales Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely Wales
Yorkshire Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely Yorkshire UK


Kuits Solicitors


Manchester Solicitors Kuits is one of the leading corporate and commercial law firms in the North West. Our approach is to work closely with our clients to understand their needs and objectives. By doing so we are able to provide tailored legal solutions.






Aaron and Partners LLP

Law Firm


Aaron Partners LLP is a leading UK law firm based in Chester and Manchester.With a total of 23 recommendations in the two leading independent legal directories covering all of our main areas of expertise we provide trusted advice to a wide range of businesses, charities, public bodies and high net worth individuals across the North West and beyond.






Hill Dickinson


Hill Dickinson LLP is a leading and award-winning international commercial law firm with more than 1,400 people including 190 partners, with offices in Liverpool, Manchester, London, Chester, Sheffield, Piraeus and Singapore. The firm delivers advice and strategic guidance spanning the full legal spectrum.






Hampson Hughes Solicitors


Hampson Hughes Solicitors are specialists in no win no fee personal injury compensation






Cassell Moore Solicitors


Cassell Moore is a leading multi-national law firm, providing first-rate legal and strategic support to our diverse client base of public and private sector businesses and individuals. Our professional, friendly and commercially aware team has secured Cassell Moore a strong nationwide presence and reputation as client centric problem solvers. The Firm is headquartered in the iconic Grade I listed Edward Pavilion at the historic Albert Dock, Liverpool and maintains offices in the leading






RECOMMENDED FOR YOU ON ENTIRELY NORTH EAST


















Cyber society a reflection


As a species, we are not very good at looking ahead. We have scientists, planners and philosophers that can shed light on our future, but in reality, we tend to respond to life on a needs must basis, kicking the can of the foreseeable down the road