s What a recent ECJ ruling means for the region's businesses
Entirely Law

NORTHWEST LEGAL NEWS

Thursday May 23 2019


What a recent ECJ ruling means for the region's businesses


A new ruling obliging all employers to ensure that adequate systems are in place to record hours worked by employees has been handed down by the ECJ. Lindsey Knowles explains what it all means.



What a recent ECJ ruling means for the region's businesses

A new ruling obliging all employers - regardless of size - across Europe to ensure that adequate systems are in place to record the exact number of hours worked by employees has been handed down by the European Court of Justice (ECJ).

The measure is an attempt to enable wronged workers to prove, should they need to, that their rights are being breached and would assist the relevant authorities and national courts to enforce those rights. But with question marks hanging over Brexit, how will such a move affect the region’s businesses?

“There has been a lot of noise around the ruling,” said Lindsey Knowles, Head of Employment Law at Kirwans law firm, “but essentially the decision simply requires employers who, under the EU Working Time Directive should be recording employees’ working hours anyway, to document a greater and more objective level of detail than they have done previously.”

The ruling came about during the case Federacion de Servicios de Comisiones Obreras (CCOO) v Deutsche Bank SAE, which was heard by Spain’s high court, the Audiencia Nacional.

Here, Spanish trade union CCOO brought legal action against financial organisation Deutsche Bank SAE. It argued that the businesses should be obliged to have a system in place that records the time worked each day by employees, so that compliance with stipulated working times can be verified. Evidence was produced that over half of overtime hours worked in Spain are not actually recorded.

“The EU Working Time Directive already sets out that workers over 18 can’t work more than 48 hours a week on average unless the worker has opted out in writing, and that employers must keep and maintain records that are ‘adequate’ to demonstrate compliance with that” Lindsey explains.

“However, the ECJ decision appears to impose an even greater obligation, and although employers in the UK are not currently required to record daily and weekly rest breaks and rest periods, the ruling could lead to that being the case in the future.

“The new measure will help employers by reminding them of the importance of keeping detailed data with regards to employee hours worked and breaks and holidays taken, and will also give them the chance to demonstrate the efforts they’re taking to ensure a healthy work/life balance for employees by complying with both EU and UK law."

Lindsey explained that the legislation is likely to stand whether or not the UK eventually leaves the EU.

“Employers have quite rightly been concerned about how they’ll be affected by the changes post-Brexit, and although EU member states have to determine specific arrangements for the implementation of such systems themselves, the current government has signalled its intention to restate all EU employment rights into UK law following our potential departure from the EU,” she said.

Refuting the suggestion that the ruling could mean the return to a punch clock, Lindsey said: “The requirement to record workers’ start, finish and break times does not necessarily mean the return to a punch clock. There can still be flexibility, as smart phones and apps can document working hours, and the ECJ did not specifically state that, for example, an email sent from home has to be recorded as work. We in the UK can decide the specifics – whether we remain in the EU or not.”



"The decision simply requires employers who should legally be recording employees working hours anyway, to document a greater and more objective level of detail than they have done previously."
Lindsey Knowles, Head of Employment Law at Kirwans








DISCLAIMER: The statements, opinions, views and advice expressed in this article are those of the author/organisation and not of ENTIRELY. This article should represent information correct at the time of publication however whilst every care has been taken to present up-to-date and accurate information, we cannot guarantee that inaccuracies will not occur. ENTIRELY will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within this article or any information accessed through this site. The content of any organisations websites which you link to from ENTIRELY are entirely out of the control of ENTIRELY, and you proceed at your own risk. These links are provided purely for your convenience and do not imply any endorsement of or association with any products, services, content, information or materials offered by or accessible to you at the organisations site.






Discover our Industry Magazines
















Discover our UK Regional Magazines


North West Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely North West UK
East of England Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely East England UK
Ireland Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely Ireland
London Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely London UK
Midlands Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely Midlands UK
North East Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely North East UK
Scotland Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely Scotland
South East Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely South East UK
South West Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely South West UK
Wales Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely Wales
Yorkshire Business News, Jobs and Events | Entirely Yorkshire UK


Hill Dickinson


Hill Dickinson LLP is a leading and award-winning international commercial law firm with more than 1,400 people including 190 partners, with offices in Liverpool, Manchester, London, Chester, Sheffield, Piraeus and Singapore. The firm delivers advice and strategic guidance spanning the full legal spectrum.






Hampson Hughes Solicitors


Hampson Hughes Solicitors are specialists in no win no fee personal injury compensation






Cassell Moore Solicitors


Cassell Moore is a leading multi-national law firm, providing first-rate legal and strategic support to our diverse client base of public and private sector businesses and individuals. Our professional, friendly and commercially aware team has secured Cassell Moore a strong nationwide presence and reputation as client centric problem solvers. The Firm is headquartered in the iconic Grade I listed Edward Pavilion at the historic Albert Dock, Liverpool and maintains offices in the leading






Bennett Williams Solicitors

Legal


Bennett Williams Solicitors is a commercial law firm specialising in debt recovery, commercial dispute resolution and insolvency law. If you need to recover a debt, resolve a commercial dispute or have a customer or client that is insolvent, we can help you.






Matrix Solicitors

Solicitors


Matrix Solicitors are a Wirral based Personal Injury Solicitors firm specialising in no win no fee compensation claims for personal injury, road traffic accidents, slip and trips and more. Visit our website to start your claim www.matrixsolicitors.net






RECOMMENDED FOR YOU ON ENTIRELY NORTH WEST