Tuesday October 22 2019

The evolving impact of Sky v Skykick on national and EU trade marks

The evolving impact of Sky v Skykick on national and EU trade marks

Advocate General Evgeni Tanchev of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has released his opinion on a landmark case which could have significant impact on the system of trade mark protection in the EU, including the UK.

The ongoing Sky v Skykick case raises several issues for consideration, which trade mark owners and practitioners will need to be wary of, including broad trade mark specifications, lack of genuine intention to use and registering trade marks in bad faith.

Sky, the well-known telecommunications company, brought proceedings for trade mark infringement and passing off against Skykick, a business providing cloud migration information technology services.

Amongst its claims, Sky relied upon a number of UK and EU trade marks for SKY in both word and logo forms which cover an extremely broad list of goods and services. In addition to terms which are in themselves broad, such as “computer software”, Sky’s trade marks also covered goods and services which, Skykick argued, Sky had no genuine intention to use the SKY mark in respect of, including “bleaching preparations” and “whips”.

One of the recommendations made by the Advocate General was that applying for an EU trade mark without any genuine intention to use it for certain goods and services applied for may, in certain circumstances, constitute bad faith, leading the mark to be invalidated at least in part.

If the Advocate General’s findings are adopted, specialist lawyers have warned that infringing parties could raise arguments regarding lack of genuine intention to use as a matter of course, and consequently costs could increase for trade mark owners looking to protect their intellectual property rights.

However, the Advocate General’s opinion would, if followed by the Court, lessen the negative impact of a finding of bad faith. The current position as stated in a previous General Court decision is that a finding that a mark is partly registered in bad faith (e.g. in respect of only some of the goods and services) is sufficient to taint the whole application, and that it should therefore be invalidated in full. In the Advocate General’s opinion, this position is incorrect and a finding of bad faith in part should result in the mark being invalidated in respect of only the goods and services to which that bad faith extends.

In respect of trade marks which include broad terms, such as “computer software”, the Advocate General concluded that a lack of clarity and precision in the specification of goods and services is not itself a ground for invalidation of a trade mark. However, certain terms, such as “computer software”, cover such a wide range of goods that it impacts upon the functioning of the trade mark. The Advocate General therefore concluded that trade marks applications which include these terms could be refused under the ground that it is contrary to public policy.

Thomas Kirby, a solicitor in the Intellectual Property team at national law firm Clarke Willmott LLP, said: “We will obviously need to wait to see if the CJEU follows the Advocate General’s opinion.

“If this is the case, new businesses will no doubt welcome the finding that broad monopolies over terms such as “computer software” could become a thing of the past.

“Trade mark owners and practitioners alike would need to be wary of applying for goods and services for which there is no genuine intention to use, but the Advocate General’s recommendation that this results in only partial invalidity takes much of the sting out of this as trade mark owners would lose only those goods or services for which they had a weaker rationale for seeking protection for in the first place.”

The case is yet to be decided but the Advocate General’s opinion plays an important and persuasive role in the decision.

Clarke Willmott is a national law firm with seven regional offices in Birmingham, Bristol, Cardiff, London, Manchester, Southampton and Taunton.

For more information visit www.clarkewillmott.com

"Trade mark owners and practitioners alike would need to be wary of applying for goods and services for which there is no genuine intention to use."
Thomas Kirby

DISCLAIMER: The statements, opinions, views and advice expressed in this article are those of the author/organisation and not of ENTIRELY. This article should represent information correct at the time of publication however whilst every care has been taken to present up-to-date and accurate information, we cannot guarantee that inaccuracies will not occur. ENTIRELY will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within this article or any information accessed through this site. The content of any organisations websites which you link to from ENTIRELY are entirely out of the control of ENTIRELY, and you proceed at your own risk. These links are provided purely for your convenience and do not imply any endorsement of or association with any products, services, content, information or materials offered by or accessible to you at the organisations site.

Entirely Law Jobs

Legal Secretary

Leighton Buzzard

Our client is seeking an experienced Legal Secretary within Probate.

Legal Secretary Conveyancing

Haywards Heath

To join our established friendly Legal practice based near Burgess Hill Our clients cover commercial /domestic Conveyancing - probate and private Client - you will require solid audio admin and copy skills together with experience of Conveyancing other areas would be helpful not essential Drafting of documents - dealing with searches Liaison with staff and clients at all levels

Supervising Associate - Employment Law


Supervising Associate - Employment Law Contract: Permanent Working Hours: Full-time Salary: Up to £60,000 per annum Chelmsford Our clients in house legal service provide high quality, professional, legal advice across the organisation to increase numbers of external clients.

Legal Secretary/Legal PA in Commercial Property


Job Spec If you are looking to work in the legal field, and be one of the main pillars driving a legal team, then look no further! Maxim Recruitment Solutions are currently recruiting for an experienced Paralegal/Secretary to assist with support duties for a prestigious law firm in Uckfield.

Legal Secretary


Introduction This is a fantastic opportunity for an experienced Legal Secretary to join an established and progressive Law Firm based in Eastbourne.

Solicitor/Legal Executive - Highways and Environment


Solicitor/Legal Executive - Highways and Environment Contract: Permanent Working Hours: Full-time Salary: Up to £45,000 per annum Chelmsford My client has an in-house legal service, one of the largest local authorities in the country.

Legal Secretaries Required in East Sussex

East Sussex

Char*Ge Legal Recruitment have some exciting new Legal Secretarial roles for some of our clients across East and West Sussex.

Legal Secretary


I have an exciting opportunity for an experienced Legal Secretary/PA to join a growing Legal firm based in the heart of Southampton.

Residential Property Legal Secretary


Residential Property Legal Secretary, West Kent The FirmThis law firm has a strong focus on building relationships within their local community, and with four offices across Kent they have built strong relationships over their 300-year history.

Legal Secretary - Brighton Based Leading Law Firm - Immediate start


An exciting opportunity has arisen for an experienced Legal Secretary to join a well-respected law firm in Brighton.

Wills & Probate Lawyer Private Client


Wills & Probate Lawyer5PQE+Solicitor/Legal ExecutiveGosportMy client, a law firm with an excellent reputation on the South Coast, are looking to add a Qualified Wills & Probate Lawyer to their expanding Private Client team in Gosport.

Home-Based Residential Conveyancer


Residential Conveyancer - National Home-Based Working Home Working Flexible Hours National My client is a specialist, national conveyancing firm with offices spanning across the UK.

Legal Secretary - Private Client

Milton Keynes

Legal Secretary - Private Client The Firm Our client is a leading commercial law firm based in Milton Keynes.


Discover the latest Industry News & Opinions on Entirely

We build powerful Financial Models for critical business decision makers.